These days I find that most of the hosting review sites are only basing their ratings on how much they can make from their affiliate associations with the web hosts. Some of the hosting companies with the absolute worst reputations are ranking at the top of most of the review sites so it is obviously a result of either being paid to have their review rank high or they make more of of those hosts, so they give them the top spots.
The whole hosting review niche has gotten such a bad rap over the last several years because of practices like this. So, based on everything I see and have seen around the web, no I do not trust most hosting review sites.
Cheers, Dean